Niagara Falls Real Estate

Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

5368 MENZIE Street
210 - Downtown Niagara Falls L2E 2V8

$1,790,000
Multi-family beds: 6 baths: 5.0 4,128 sq. ft. built: 1850

View of front of home
Photo 1: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 2: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 3: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 4: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 5: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 6: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 7: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 8: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 9: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 10: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 11: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 12: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 13: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 14: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 15: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 16: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 17: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 18: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 19: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 20: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 21: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 22: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 23: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 24: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 25: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 26: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 27: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 28: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 29: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 30: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 31: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 32: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 33: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 34: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 35: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 36: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 37: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 38: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 39: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 40: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 41: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 42: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 43: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 44: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 45: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 46: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 47: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Photo 48: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Multi-family
MLS® Num:
40790984
Bedrooms:
6
Bathrooms:
5
Year Built:
1850
Own a Rare Piece of Niagara's History - Endless Possibilities Await!Step into a truly one-of-a-kind estate where timeless elegance meets modern convenience. Legal 5-plex, this extraordinary property is currently configured as a spacious single-family home, and can be effortlessly returned back to a 5-plex income producer. It also presents an amazing bed & breakfast opportunity, especially with the impressive Viking pool. A rare luxury that sets this property apart. Boasting over 4,000 sq. ft. of living space, the home features remarkable architectural character, including 12' ceilings, original hardwood floors, solid 8' doors, intricate cove moulding, detailed plaster trim, a grand staircase, and a stunning solid marble fireplace mantel. Located just minutes from Niagara Falls' premier entertainment district, this property also offers dual street access, a rare advantage in Niagara plus ample parking. Additional highlights include: Empty apartments, allowing the new owner to set market rents. Development opportunities at the rear of the property. You can build 3 homes or possibly 5 towns. Ideal for a home-based business: perfect for a salon, daycare, accounting office, law office, or other professional use. If geared toward students, the layout offers numerous rooms, maximizing income potential. Revenue potential of up to $10,000 per month, depending on use and configuration. Over the past 26 years, nearly every major system has been updated, including: High-efficiency furnace & AC, newer windows and exterior doors, a 200-amp electrical panel, rebuilt back porch, updated fencing, and more (see the full upgrade sheet for details). Whether you're seeking a distinctive residence, a high-yield investment property, or a boutique hospitality venture, this rare gem delivers unmatched versatility, historic charm, and modern reliability. Envision the possibilities! (id:2493)
Property Type:
Multi-family
Common Interest:
Freehold
Total Living Area:
4,128 sq. ft.
Finished Area Above Grade:
4,128 sq. ft.
Zoning:
R2
Taxes:
$6,705 / -
Community:
210 - Downtown
Exterior Features:
Vinyl siding
Pool Features:
Inground pool
Community Features:
School Bus
Bedrooms:
6
Bathrooms:
5.0
Cooling:
Central air conditioning
Fireplace:
No
Foundation:
Stone
Heating:
Forced air, Natural gas
# Storeys:
3.0
Water:
Municipal water
Sewer:
Municipal sewage system
Basement:
Unfinished, Full
Lot Frontage:
96'
Lot Features:
Paved Driveway
Total Parking Spaces:
10
  • Photo 1: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of front of home
  • Photo 2: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of front of home with a chimney, a front lawn, a shingled roof, and driveway
  • Photo 3: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of front of home with a chimney, a front lawn, and asphalt driveway
  • Photo 4: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of front facade
  • Photo 5: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Property entrance
  • Photo 6: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of side of property with a chimney, a yard, and asphalt driveway
  • Photo 7: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Multi unit property with stairs, roof with shingles, and a balcony
  • Photo 8: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Property back entrance
  • Photo 9: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Wooden deck with stairway
  • Photo 10: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    wooden deck
  • Photo 11: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Living area with a chandelier, light wood-style floors, a fireplace, and crown molding
  • Photo 12: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Living area featuring a chandelier, ornamental molding, and light wood-style flooring
  • Photo 13: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Detailed view of a chandelier, wood finished floors, and a premium fireplace
  • Photo 14: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Dining area with light wood-style floors
  • Photo 15: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Full bathroom featuring shower / tub combo and toilet
  • Photo 16: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Kitchen featuring white dishwasher, white cabinets, light wood-style flooring, decorative backsplash, and freestanding refrigerator
  • Photo 17: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Kitchen with dishwasher, black range with gas cooktop, dark countertops, light wood-style flooring, and tasteful backsplash
  • Photo 18: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Foyer entrance featuring light wood-type flooring and ornamental molding
  • Photo 19: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Staircase featuring carpet flooring and baseboards
  • Photo 20: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Photo 20 of 48
  • Photo 21: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Hall featuring carpet flooring and an upstairs landing
  • Photo 22: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Bedroom with carpet floors
  • Photo 23: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Workout area featuring carpet floors and a ceiling fan
  • Photo 24: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Home office with healthy amount of natural light and carpet flooring
  • Photo 25: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Full bathroom featuring toilet and tile patterned flooring
  • Photo 26: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Bedroom featuring a textured ceiling, carpet flooring, a ceiling fan, and connected bathroom
  • Photo 27: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Carpeted bedroom featuring a textured ceiling and ceiling fan
  • Photo 28: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Carpeted bedroom featuring baseboards
  • Photo 29: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Kitchen featuring light countertops, white cabinetry, and dark wood-style flooring
  • Photo 30: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Full bathroom featuring a wainscoted wall, a soaking tub, and crown molding
  • Photo 31: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Bonus room with wood finished floors, built in features, vaulted ceiling, and a ceiling fan
  • Photo 32: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Photo 32 of 48
  • Photo 33: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Bonus room featuring light wood finished floors and vaulted ceiling
  • Photo 34: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Full bathroom featuring vaulted ceiling, a bath, vanity, tile patterned flooring, and tiled shower
  • Photo 35: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Office area featuring crown molding and wood finished floors
  • Photo 36: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Kitchen featuring white appliances, dark countertops, plenty of natural light, and a chandelier
  • Photo 37: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Full bath featuring tile patterned floors, decorative backsplash, and shower / washtub combination
  • Photo 38: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Living area with plenty of natural light, hardwood / wood-style floors, ceiling fan, and ornamental molding
  • Photo 39: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Living area featuring healthy amount of natural light, hardwood / wood-style floors, ceiling fan, and ornamental molding
  • Photo 40: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Living area featuring a ceiling fan, coffered ceiling, wood finished floors, and crown molding
  • Photo 41: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of swimming pool with a patio area and a fenced backyard
  • Photo 42: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Back of property featuring a storage shed, a patio area, roof with shingles, and a fenced backyard
  • Photo 43: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Rear view of house featuring a balcony, a shed, a patio area, and a fenced backyard
  • Photo 44: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Rear view of house featuring a patio, a storage shed, a shingled roof, and a balcony
  • Photo 45: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Aerial perspective of suburban area
  • Photo 46: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    Wooden terrace with stairway
  • Photo 47: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of balcony
  • Photo 48: 5368 MENZIE Street in Niagara Falls: Multi-family for sale : MLS®# 40790984
    View of front of home with stairway, a shingled roof, a chimney, a metal roof, and a deck
Listed by RE/MAX Niagara Realty Ltd.
Data was last updated November 29, 2025 at 01:45 PM (UTC)
Area Statistics
Listings on market:
20
Avg list price:
$774,945
Min list price:
$299,900
Max list price:
$1,800,000
Avg days on market:
68
Min days on market:
2
Max days on market:
228
Avg price per sq.ft.:
$260.51
These statistics are generated based on the current listing's property type and located in 210 - Downtown. Average values are derived using median calculations. This data is not produced by the MLS® system.
KRISTIN DEDIVITIIS
Judy Sweeting
The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are member’s of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.